How Australia’s Robodebt scandal is claiming its victims

WhatsAppWhatsAppFacebookFacebookTwitterTwitterPinterestPinterestRedditRedditGmailGmailShareShare

“It was just really beyond my comprehension, how they could be asking me for that money,” said Nathan Kearney, 33, who received an automated call from Australia’s welfare agency in 2016 saying he owed them thousands of dollars. This was just the beginning of his five years long ordeal.

What followed next was a series of harassing phone calls from debt collectors. His tax rebate was withheld to pay A$2,000 (RM5,933) worth of arrears that government said he owed. A year later he was sent another debt notice saying he owed them about A$4,000 (RM11,867). He had to move in with his parents to survive this. “It was the only way that I could imagine being able to cope financially,” said Kearney, whose “debts spiralled even higher after he bought countless sessions of therapy to tackle his depression.

Kearney is just one of other 400,000 recipients of welfare in Australia who have been accused of reporting false earnings and have been slapped with huge fines consequently. The errors are due to an automated debt recovery scheme, called as Robodebt, that was established by the former conservative coalition government.

Keep Reading

The algorithm of the said scheme is completely messed up as it “wrongly calculated that the welfare recipients owed money and so issued a ream of debt notices”. During the period of its operations from July 2015 to November 2019, the scheme had used algorithms that calculated the overpayments, “raising more than A$1.7bil (RM5.04bil), which the government was forced to repay or wipe when a court ruled the scheme unlawful in 2019”.

The Labor government announced beginning of an inquiry in August, Government Services Minister Bill Shorten called Robodebt a “shameful chapter in the history of public administration”, and a “massive failure of policy and law”. A Royal Commission, that is a very powerful type of government inquiry, is now investigating the Robodebt scheme.

This is an excellent case of high Artificial Intelligence (AI), that is increasingly being used by governments across the world to process claims into welfare schemes, is actually not error-proof. “Such schemes are inherently problematic, and often fail because they lack all humanity,” said Tapani Rinta-Kahila, a professor at the University of Queensland who studies the use of AI in the public sector. “No matter how good an algorithm you have, no matter how sophisticated it is, it still cannot address fundamental human issues as sensitive as welfare,” he said.

About Senior Reporter

With over more than 6 years of writing obituaries for the local paper, Senior Reporter has a uniquely strong voice that shines through in his newest collection of essays and articles, which explores the importance we place on the legacy.

Senior Reporter

With over more than 6 years of writing obituaries for the local paper, Senior Reporter has a uniquely strong voice that shines through in his newest collection of essays and articles, which explores the importance we place on the legacy.

Recent Posts

US H-1B Visa Registrations Hit Three-Year Low Amid Trump-Era Rules and Rising Immigration Barriers

The total registrations for H-1B visas for U.S. fiscal year 2026 (FY26) are the lowest since FY22, which points to…

May 20, 2025

Ex-Judge Richard Posner Wins Lawsuit Over $170K Pay Dispute

Former U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Posner has won a lawsuit from Indiana man, Brian Vukadinovich who claimed he was owed…

May 20, 2025

New Protections Proposed for Pregnant Agency Workers in Isle of Man

On the Isle of Man, the government is intending to extend health and safety protections to pregnant agency workers who…

May 20, 2025

US Stamps Out Illegal Migration: Visa Bans Target Top Indian Travel Agency Leaders

The United States has declared that it would impose visa restrictions on owners, executives, and senior officials of India-based travel…

May 20, 2025

New Jersey Rail Workers Call Off Strike, Commuter Services Resume Tuesday

The New Jersey rail workers ended their strike after three days when the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET)…

May 19, 2025

Philippines Digital Nomad Visa: Eligibility, Benefits and Top Remote Work Destinations

The Philippines has announced its addition to a long list of countries that are welcoming remote workers with the launch…

May 19, 2025